The Last Airbender
Dec. 10th, 2010 11:51 amOh man, this is terrible. I mean, you knew that, but wow. Not since Manos have I seen the MST3K crew have such a hard time with a movie. It's really its own best argument for racebending, because one look at this movie and you know these kids couldn't have been the best actors to audition. It's hard to tell if they're genuinely terrible or horribly directed with abyssal dialogue, but basically, every time the camera is on Zuko and Iroh, you feel like you're watching a kinda cool movie with neat costumes and compelling characters, then it switches to the Gaang and it's like you're watching a school play.
Moreover, this is possibly the worst adaptation I've ever seen. It's like if you gave someone a two-hour blank tape and asked them to tape all the important parts of the first season of Avatar... and then when you played it, they didn't skip the commercials. Yes, despite watching this on Blu-Ray, this movie presents the incredible feeling of being infested with commercials. Nothing seems to happen, and it's all happening at this breakneck pace. Aang gets freed from the ice and then immediately gets captured by the Fire Nation. Sokka and Yue pretty much take one look at each other and fall in love. It's awful.
Oh, and I know I'm like the restaurant patron who complained that the food was bad and the portions were too small, but that half-hour of cut material? Not on the Blu-Ray. There's about eleven minutes of deleted scenes, and most of them are black people dancing and extended fight scenes. I wanted to see the Kyoshi Warriors, if only to laugh at the awfulness. They really just make a cameo after an Earth Kingdom village gets freed, randomly stepping out from behind a crowd to flash their fans at the departing Gaang, then disappearing again while Sokka makes a DUR face. It's a nice Easter egg, so I wonder why they cut it out. It makes a lot more sense than including Azula for a cliffhanger ending. Yeah, that'll make sense to mainstream audiences. "Oh no, he's sending a 14-year-old girl after them! How will Aang get out of this one!"
There's also a scene where Aang meets with a literal Mystical Negro that was cut because he actually makes facial expressions in it.
Just... did no one ask any questions here? Like, isn't it a little silly to have Aang do a whole cheer routine just so he can use the air to push someone back a few feet? Or script notes, they still do that, right? Why does Aang get captured by the Fire Nation four times only to immediately escape each time? Why include Momo if he doesn't even do anything? And I don't mean, like, in terms of plot, I mean, he doesn't even look cute or get into comedy hijinks. He's just there. What's the point?
It's just such a bizarre blend of slavishly detrimental faithfulness to the source and change for the sake of change (like how to pronounce the character's names). Like, okay, why introduce a love interest in the third act and then expect her heroic sacrifice to mean something? Why not introduce her sooner and makes the heroes' goal to get her to the Northern Water Tribe? Or why have Aang immediately find out his people were killed and then angst about it for the rest of the movie? Why not have him hold out hope for a while, then get to the Northern Air Temple and find out about the genocide, giving him a long dark night of the soul to launch the third act? Or hell, why not cut out Zhao? He and Zuko have this entire conflict that has nothing to do with the rest of the movie, so why not give the fish-punching to Zuko to give him a "My god what have I done?" moment to kick-off his redemption arc?
I could take drastic departures from the source material if they had a point. But there's literally no thematic unity, no plot thoroughfare, no character arc, no central conflict, and no story structure in this movie. It's just a bunch of random scenes, so what's included and what's cut out doesn't have any bearing on anything. Also, racism.
Moreover, this is possibly the worst adaptation I've ever seen. It's like if you gave someone a two-hour blank tape and asked them to tape all the important parts of the first season of Avatar... and then when you played it, they didn't skip the commercials. Yes, despite watching this on Blu-Ray, this movie presents the incredible feeling of being infested with commercials. Nothing seems to happen, and it's all happening at this breakneck pace. Aang gets freed from the ice and then immediately gets captured by the Fire Nation. Sokka and Yue pretty much take one look at each other and fall in love. It's awful.
Oh, and I know I'm like the restaurant patron who complained that the food was bad and the portions were too small, but that half-hour of cut material? Not on the Blu-Ray. There's about eleven minutes of deleted scenes, and most of them are black people dancing and extended fight scenes. I wanted to see the Kyoshi Warriors, if only to laugh at the awfulness. They really just make a cameo after an Earth Kingdom village gets freed, randomly stepping out from behind a crowd to flash their fans at the departing Gaang, then disappearing again while Sokka makes a DUR face. It's a nice Easter egg, so I wonder why they cut it out. It makes a lot more sense than including Azula for a cliffhanger ending. Yeah, that'll make sense to mainstream audiences. "Oh no, he's sending a 14-year-old girl after them! How will Aang get out of this one!"
There's also a scene where Aang meets with a literal Mystical Negro that was cut because he actually makes facial expressions in it.
Just... did no one ask any questions here? Like, isn't it a little silly to have Aang do a whole cheer routine just so he can use the air to push someone back a few feet? Or script notes, they still do that, right? Why does Aang get captured by the Fire Nation four times only to immediately escape each time? Why include Momo if he doesn't even do anything? And I don't mean, like, in terms of plot, I mean, he doesn't even look cute or get into comedy hijinks. He's just there. What's the point?
It's just such a bizarre blend of slavishly detrimental faithfulness to the source and change for the sake of change (like how to pronounce the character's names). Like, okay, why introduce a love interest in the third act and then expect her heroic sacrifice to mean something? Why not introduce her sooner and makes the heroes' goal to get her to the Northern Water Tribe? Or why have Aang immediately find out his people were killed and then angst about it for the rest of the movie? Why not have him hold out hope for a while, then get to the Northern Air Temple and find out about the genocide, giving him a long dark night of the soul to launch the third act? Or hell, why not cut out Zhao? He and Zuko have this entire conflict that has nothing to do with the rest of the movie, so why not give the fish-punching to Zuko to give him a "My god what have I done?" moment to kick-off his redemption arc?
I could take drastic departures from the source material if they had a point. But there's literally no thematic unity, no plot thoroughfare, no character arc, no central conflict, and no story structure in this movie. It's just a bunch of random scenes, so what's included and what's cut out doesn't have any bearing on anything. Also, racism.