seriousfic: (Default)
seriousfic ([personal profile] seriousfic) wrote2010-04-28 02:38 am
Entry tags:

Glee - oh my, this is shit

Perhaps it's that since LotS was cancelled, I hate every show that's been renewed (EAT A POPCORN BOWL OF DICKS, WIZARDS OF WAVERLY PLACE!). But even so, I've never seen a show so blatantly sell out to what it's supposedly satirizing. It was like seeing an episode of BtVS where Buffy has sex, then runs screaming from a monster before being gruesomely killed. Or an episode of Generation Kill where Colbert punches out bin Laden. "This is for the North Tower! This is for the South Tower! And this... is for AMMMMMMEEEEEERRRRRIIIIIIICCCCCCCAAAAAA!"

I could point to how forced the musical numbers were (Are you even allowed to say "Hi, let's have a duet!" in a musical? You shouldn't be) or how our flawed yet sympathetic characters were suddenly forced into delivering predigested after-school specialisms, or how a band of freaks and outcasts are suddenly able to hijack the cheerleading squad and deliver a Very Special Message to the student body (who applaud wildly, because wasn't the absolute best part of high school those student assemblies where they told us how it was what was inside that counted, and that we should believe in ourselves, and that if there were any gay people in the audience, they had to go to Fake Prom?). Let me just sum it up this way: At the climax, that "You are beautiful" song was performed in dead seriousness. Yes, the most sappy, cynicism-inducing song since the one about Christmas Shoes was not only put into show choir form, it was performed without even the salve of sweet, sweet irony.

Not even Brittana physical affection could redeem this. And don't think it didn't try!

[identity profile] potatoko.livejournal.com 2010-04-28 11:18 am (UTC)(link)
Ryan Murphy shows always have this problem: good concept, sharp characters with often hilarious dialogue to start with, but eventually degenerating into patronising, parable laden mush fests. Took longer in Popular, if I remember rightly, though I was a young teenager then and not quite so filled with hate. When Popular turned south I naively blamed network intervention, but it seems he just runs out of ideas pretty quickly.

I will still be watching it for the Brittana, of course. But I'm going to resent every second!

[identity profile] mcity.livejournal.com 2010-04-28 04:35 pm (UTC)(link)
Counterpoint: Sue.

[identity profile] solitarysputnik.livejournal.com 2010-04-28 06:05 pm (UTC)(link)
Honestly, her cartoonish sociopathic supervillainy is what keeps me watching.
That, and the occasional fantastic number - something this week somewhat lacked.
I mean, Fire wasn't bad, but it was no Halo/Sunshine, say.

[identity profile] scottyquick.livejournal.com 2010-04-29 12:58 pm (UTC)(link)
Sue + Quinn + Kristen Chenoweth (PUSHING DAISIES!) + Idina Menzel (umph and DAT VOICE) + Johnathan Groff (umph and DAT VOICE) = I will be watching this show.